Archives for May 2013

Vacation!

I'm sorry...I'm really not ignoring you. Well, actually I am, but I don't mean to be rude and it's only temporary. I will be on vacation for the next few days. If you happen to post a comment to my blog in the meantime and don't see it appear, please be patient. The website admin is officially off duty until next Tuesday, so your comments may not be approved beforehand. The timing of this vacation is a little unfortunate, given the recent flurry of activity in the comments from last month's post, my open letter to Jerry Coyne. There have been some interesting comments, particularly one by Dr. Leblanc, that merit further consideration in respectful discourse. Alas, the grandchildren have been promised a quick trip to Florida that was planned well in advance. Grandpa must not disappoint. Perhaps in the interim, Dr. Coyne will find the time to grade his compatibilism quiz that I took yesterday. Some very interesting conversation may be about to happen, possibly as soon as next week. If Dr. Coyne chooses not to participate, Dr. Leblanc seems a more than capable substitute, and he is willing to engage in serious dialog. Stay tuned! I don't think you'll want to miss it. … [Read more...]

Jerry Coyne’s compatibilism quiz

While I’ve been waiting and hoping for Dr. Coyne to respond to my questions about speciation theory, I’ve periodically scanned his blog Why Evolution is True to see if the opportunity has arisen for him to answer my questions. I'm sure that Dr. Coyne is a very busy man, and he just hasn’t had time to respond thus far. Of course, he had to travel and give a lecture at Appalachian State, take pictures to show off his spiffy new ostrich boots, make several gratuitous attacks on creationism and religion with cheesy cartoons, and time to post lots of cat pictures on his blog. But no time for me yet. I’m sure he’ll get around to my questions, eventually. Apparently, he does respond to email. In the meantime, in one of the sixty-plus blogs posted since my letter, Dr. Coyne published a pop quiz on compatibilism. I love a good challenge, so I’ve taken his quiz. Perhaps he'll even grade my answers. Thank goodness that Dr. Coyne helpfully defined compatibilism as “free will that accepts material determinism.” I must confess that I didn't know the definition, and the closest dictionary didn't offer me one. Because I accept genetics, DNA, and the power of heredity, I can also accept the concept of material determinism, at least up to a point. However, I must reject the proposal that people can’t be held morally responsible for their actions. In fact, I find that suggestion both appalling and absurd. Is Ariel Castro, recently arrested in Cleveland for kidnapping three women and holding them captive for a decade, only guilty of committing egregious evil … [Read more...]

The problem with PETA

PETA founder Ingrid Newkirk rather famously once said, “A rat is a pig is a dog is a boy”, but she was absolutely wrong. The truth is that a rat is vermin, and a pig could be dinner. A dog might be a boy’s best friend, but they are obviously different species, rather easy to tell apart. Don't get me wrong...I love my dogs, very much. They are my furry babies. Truthfully, I wouldn’t even think twice about risking my own life by running into traffic to save one of them from an oncoming car. In fact, there’s precedent for my saying so. Not long ago I foolishly ran onto a major highway near my house and nearly got myself killed, trying to save someone else’s dog that had escaped from under their fence. The story had a happy ending that day. They don’t always end that way. We both were lucky, the dog and me. I was acting purely on altruistic instinct, a natural reaction that a guy like Jerry Coyne might mistake for goodness. Nevertheless, if the choice is between saving either a dog or a child, the human life comes first in my mind. That’s also an instinctive decision, a no-brainer. In my world, God gave mankind dominion over all other animals. That means we have a tremendous responsibility to act as good stewards. In the world I prefer, it’s okay to kill a cow or chicken--as long as you eat it. It’s even okay to make clothing from the animal’s hide, so nothing is wasted. While doing so, we should most certainly give thanks to its Creator for the sacrifice of the animal for food and clothing, for the life we used to help sustain ours. However, in … [Read more...]